Are people inherently:
Good or Bad?
Smart or Dumb?
These assumptions, like all assumptions, will frame any judgement you make. If you believe people are inherently smart, you'll get out of their way and let them do their thing. If you believe people are inherently dumb, you will be inclined to "help" people by deciding for them. Good, you'll get out of their way. Bad, you'll put up controls and checks. The same holds true for corporations and governments.
Let's make a grid:
Good Bad
Smart Freedom Police State
Dumb Paternal Asylum State(?)
I'm not sure anyone thinks people are inherently dumb and bad (please point me at someone who does, it would make for an interesting read).
Personally, I'll go with Smart and Good with the caveat, as pointed out in Agile Software Development, that people are inconsistent. I'll agree with Reagan, "Trust, but verify."